Hello, @Rkleyn. 

Allow me to join the conversation. 

Since you're getting the same error in exporting your data to Excel, I suggest following the recommended steps by @BigRedConsulting to get rid of the error. 

For your future reference about several reports available in QuickBooks and how to generate them, please visit this article: 

Excel based payroll reports

Let me know how it goes by clicking the Reply button below. I'm always here to help. Take good care!