It appears that your question has been revamped, mroscorla.

I understand your concern about the matter involving memorized reports in QuickBooks. It's frustrating to lose recently created reports during data utilities, especially when the file doctor isn't able to resolve the problem.

Typically, we would escalate this issue to our QuickBooks Desktop Support for a more in-depth investigation. However, I'm unable to do so as the version of QuickBooks you're using has already been retired. My suggestion is to consider upgrading to the latest version. You can reach out to the team to inquire about purchasing the latest version or call the sales team.

Please don't hesitate to go back to this thread if you have other questions in mind.