Welcome to the thread, RTLcreativeaccounting.

Since the invoice has settled, then you'll need to create a new one to apply it to the new card.

For additional reference, you may find below articles helpful:

• How to Create a Customer Invoice
• Record invoice payments in QuickBooks Online
• Receive an invoice payment using the QuickBooks Online app

You're always welcome to come by the Community. Any time you need assistance, we're always here to help. Take care and enjoy the rest of your day!