Thanks for joining the conversation, @innouttruck,

You don't need to select the Run Payroll option to print the paystubs, go to the Paycheck List instead. Here's how:

1. From the Workers menu, tap the Employees tab.
2. Tap the Paycheck List link.
   
3. Mark the paychecks you want then hit Print.
   

Here's an article with the complete steps on printing checks in QBO: Print pay stubs.

We are always open if you have other questions. I'm also here to provide further assistance whenever you need one. Have a wonderful day, @innouttruck!