Yes, it'll create new paychecks, cec2.

For recording purposes, you can enter the prior payroll as paychecks for both payment method as to avoid sending them again. I'll show you how to remove the Use Direct Deposit option. 

1. From the Payroll Center, start creating payroll.
2. In the Enter Payroll Information window, click Open Paycheck Detail.
3. At the upper-right of the Preview Paycheck window, uncheck the Use Direct Deposit box. 
4. After entering the amount and correct dates, click Save & Close.
5. Click Continue and then Create paychecks.

If you need more help with enter paychecks you can use this article: How do I create a paycheck for an employee?.

I'll be here if there's anything else you need help with. You take care and keep safe!