Hello, @MMotors.

This may need to be investigated further. It seems odd why the withholding is not calculating correctly after attempting several troubleshooting steps. 

I'd recommend attempting to use the verify/rebuild tool first to check if there are any data issues within your company file. If the issue persists, please contact our Desktop Technical Support so they can dig deeper into this issue using their tools.

If you have additional questions, do let me know by commenting below. I'm here to help however I can.