Thank you for the response, @AcctnAsst!

You'll have to select only one payroll item for your paycheck. I'm here to share a few insights and help you from there.

To start with, the prompt message will appear once you've selected more than one payroll item in your Earnings table.

With this, you can only proceed once you select either Bonus or Annual Salary of your payroll item.

For your reference, please see attached screenshot below.

In addition, you can follow the detailed steps outlined by my colleague, @JaneD, so you can successfully create your paycheck.

Also, if there a need for you to enter another payroll item in your Earnings table, you can enter it when you create your next payroll.

Lastly, you can check this helpful article for your future reference: Who have I Paid this Month?

It'll be always my pleasure to help if you have any other questions. I'll be keeping an eye for your response.