@DebSheenD the link to the accounting preferences article is not working.

Also, my accounting preferences are correct. 

Here are two screenshots showing how my pay comes up. The top is viewing the account where my wages are going. The "Expense" transaction is the net pay and the "payroll" check is the full gross pay. 

In the second shot, this is how the expense transactions are now showing in my Review Transactions for my bank account.