I just spent 4 hours with QBO support yesterday for this very thing.  The rule applies to everything properly except the transactions brought in automatically from Paypal, which have the most detail.  I can manually switch it from Sales Receipt to Deposit and all is well.  However having to do that for hundreds of transactions is mind numbing and defeats the purpose of the rule.  After a long afternoon of them trying to figure it out, they told me to go to Paypal.  I hung up very upset.  This is how QBO is handling things once they are there.  Paypal has nothing to do with it.  I need the rule to change it to Deposit, but it won't.