I was able to talk to American support and she actually listened to what I was saying, and verified what her side looked like compared to my side. She acknowledged that it was different. 

My URL for the matching has this "newadvancedmatch" section. She has me delete the NEW and the 'old' match screen popped up and I could once again automatically match transactions.

https://qbo.intuit.com/app/newadvancedmatch?id=5310:ofx&date=2025-04-06 

I was advised to leave feedback for the engineers through the settings tab. HOPEFULLY this is an oversight and isn't the new QBO online.

Attaching an image of how it worked prior to the new advanced search match. As you can see there is a suggested matches toggle button, and it then has a button for the X number of receipts you can select.