As MANY have stated, this is still a problem. I have created recurring transactions reminders so that I can track when data has been entered. For example, I enter a payroll journal entry as the client uses something other than QB for payroll. I have reminders set for every other week to be able to make sure I don't miss entering a JE. When I have entered the data for a week, I expect to have that reminder gone. Now, I have to remember to skip the reminder after I've entered it or else I have to go back into reports to see if it was entered the next time I work on that client. We have had duplicate entries many times due to this issue and employees not checking to see if an entry had already been done. The point of using these reminders vs having a spreadsheet to check off when work has been completed is to save time. Constantly messing up a good working system with updates is one of many reasons Intuit/QB is losing customers. Just fix the issue. 
I want to be able to go to my reminders, click edit/create, complete the transaction, and then have it leave my list of reminders. It's done. I don't need to keep seeing it or have to take extra steps to clear it. FIX IT.