I appreciate such detailed information about your concern, Suzygirlnc.

You've already pointed out the possible causes as to why contractors are showing up as being below threshold instead of the other way around.

Since the issue continues after considering the recommended steps above, it would be best to contact our support for further investigation. They can help identify the cause of why contractors that should supposedly show up on the meet threshold criteria are showing up as being below the threshold.

Here's how you can reach us:

1. Go to the Help menu at the upper right.
2. Select Contact Us.
3. Enter your concern.
4. Click Let’s talk.
5. Choose Get a callback. 
6. Type in your contact info.
7. Select Confirm my call.

Click on the QuickBooks Online (QBO) drop-down to see the most updated support schedule: Support hours and types.

Here are some resources that you might need for additional information about managing 1099s in QuickBooks Online (QBO):

• Common questions about 1099s
• Prepare and file 1099s
• Create a 1099 report for vendors and vendor payments
• 1099 Troubleshooting

If there's anything I can help you with, feel free to drop me a reply below. Hope you have a good one.