I ran the diagnostic tool as well as the QB File Doctor and it did not fix the issue.
One more thing I should mention - we run QB from a server. I checked the computer on the server and it does not have this problem. I also checked QB on my colleagues computer and the problem does not happen on it either. It only happens on my computer. And it wasn't happening until very recently. The last time I used the "Make A Deposit" field was about 2 months ago and it was normal.
