Hello there, @czieman.
Let me share some steps to delete the OH-school district tax item in the employee's profile.
QuickBooks automatically adds any missing "Other Tax" payroll items for your state when you add a new employee, review the tax setup in the Employee Defaults window, or change in the employee record.
To delete the payroll item, you need to confirm the change by selecting the Yes or No button in the pop-up window. In your case, you need to select No to remove the item.
If you get the same result, let's run some troubleshooting steps to fix possible data issues. To start, update the QuickBooks to the latest release. Sometimes downloading and installing the latest updates fix minor issues within the program or file.
After that, run the Verify and Rebuild tools. This process can locate the issue and to correct the errors. You can follow the steps in this article: Resolve Data Damage on your Company File.
For more information, I've attached some articles you can use as your guide for 2019 year-end:
Please know that I'm only a post away if you have any other questions. Have a great day ahead.
